Music on My Terms
For my Interrail trip in 2027, there will probably be times when I'll want to listen to music. Music is important to me and, while I'm not one for walking around with earbuds permanently attached to my ears, there's something rather nice in the idea of listening to your favourite bands while watching the European countryside roll past a train window.
Which got me thinking about my music collection.
Looking through the Amazon Music app this afternoon, I discovered that I've bought around 200 albums through Amazon over the years. I remember when they first started selling digital downloads. I was rather taken with the idea that I could buy an album and listen to it on my phone. No discs to carry around, no need to rip CDs onto a computer. It seemed a marvellous idea.
Then things changed.
Amazon introduced its Unlimited subscription service, which allows you to listen to pretty much whatever you fancy, provided you keep paying your subscription. Fair enough. If that's how you want to listen to music, crack on.
But then Amazon started introducing adverts into the music stream, even when I was listening to music I'd actually paid for. And then, to add insult to injury, other music started appearing while I was listening to an album.
That was a step too far.
I'm of the generation that buys an album and listens to it from beginning to end. That's how the artist intended it to be heard, and that's how I like to listen. I don't want adverts interrupting the experience, and I certainly don't want somebody else's choice of music appearing halfway through an album I've selected.
I want to listen to the music I've bought. Is that really too much to ask?
This afternoon, I started looking at those 200 or so albums sitting in my Amazon account. Two hundred albums that I've paid good money for, and which I'd quite like to listen to without somebody else deciding how that experience should work.
It also got me thinking about the cost of digital music.
When you buy a CD, you're paying for the disc itself, the packaging, the booklet and everything else that goes into producing and distributing a physical product. With a digital download, none of that is required. I appreciate there are still costs involved in digital distribution and licensing, but surely they can't be equivalent to producing, packaging and distributing a physical CD?
Yet I've paid the full asking price for plenty of digital albums over the years.
So what exactly have I bought?
I appreciate that younger generations have different ways of listening to music. Streaming is convenient, and I can see the attraction of having millions of tracks available at the touch of a button.
But I grew up in a time when you went into a record shop, browsed the racks and bought a vinyl record. Later, I embraced CDs, which seemed like a technological leap forward.
And I still buy CDs today.
Perhaps I'm simply a product of my time. Or perhaps there's a difference between buying a copy of an album and paying a monthly subscription for access to it. When I buy a CD, I have a physical copy that I can play whenever I want, without having to keep paying for the privilege. With a subscription, my access to the music depends on continuing to pay each month. There certainly is a difference in my mind.
When I buy a CD, I can play it whenever I want. I can listen to the whole album, put individual tracks into a playlist, or make a compilation of my favourite songs. We used to call those mixtapes, incidentally. There are no adverts, no interruptions and no reminders that I ought to subscribe to something.
The CD doesn't suddenly decide that I'd probably prefer to listen to a different artist.
I know I'm sounding a bit old-fashioned, but I like having unrestricted access to my music. Most importantly, I like being able to listen to it on my terms, rather than according to the terms and conditions of a company that would really rather I paid it a monthly subscription.
I have a Hi-Fi system, and I still spend time listening to the CDs I've collected over the years. They're not a random assortment of discs bought on a whim. They're a carefully curated collection of music that means something to me.
There isn't a CD in the house by an artist I dislike. That would rather defeat the object.
My collection is, in its own way, a reflection of my musical personality. And it's a fairly eclectic one, too. I've got classical, folk, rock, heavy metal, doom metal, industrial, progressive rock, pop, rockabilly and punk. There are favourites, of course, but I enjoy wandering between genres depending on my mood.
My digital collection is much the same. Those 200 albums aren't just a collection of tracks in a streaming library. I chose them, paid for them and wanted them in my collection.
Which brings me back to my original problem.
How do I listen to those digital albums on my Interrail trip?
I could buy an MP3 player, perhaps one of those modern equivalents of the old iPod. I'm not particularly interested in buying an Apple product, though. I don't want to exchange one company's restrictions for another's.
The frustrating thing is that Amazon doesn't make it particularly easy to retrieve a large collection of music that you've purchased digitally. You can download eligible purchases, but managing a collection of this size is another matter. And the whole experience seems designed to encourage you towards Amazon Music Unlimited rather than help you make the most of the music you've already bought.
Why can't I simply download a zip file containing all the albums I've purchased? They're my purchases, made legally and paid for in full. I'd happily store them on a computer, transfer them to an MP3 player and take them away with me.
Instead, I'm left wondering how best to get my own music onto a device that will let me listen to it without interference.
All of which seems rather ridiculous.
I'm planning a railway journey across Europe. I want to sit by a train window, watch the world go by and listen to some of my favourite albums.
Apparently, even that is unnecessarily difficult now.
I hear you! As you know I read a lot and have hundreds of books on both the Kindle and Kobo ecosystems. Paid for but digital; I can’t lend them to family, I can’t part-ex those that I know I won’t want to read again and I can’t gift my collection when I pass. It’s been on my mind recently so when you recommended the Herriot books I bought the box set … the physical books themselves. Digital downloads are very convenient, books and music, but with none of the physical costs they do seem over-priced. I know servers and storage and management software also costs money but surely not as much as physically producing tangible goods, transporting them and selling them in a real store.
ReplyDelete💯 agree
ReplyDelete